external hemorrhoids swelling - Medical Diagnosis -treating Hemorrhoids - How to Choose the Least Painful and Most Suitable Option

Medical Diagnosis -treating Hemorrhoids - How to Choose the Least Painful and Most Suitable Option

Treating hemorrhoids - how to choose the least painful and most suitable option

After consulting various specialists, each recommending his own pet method of treatment, a hemorrhoid sufferer gets online medical advice for choosing the least painful and most suitable treatment option.

After being diagnosed with 'hemorrhoidal pathology" (3rd degree hemorrhoids, polyp in the anal canal), the 37 year-old male patient consulted various medical services and specialists, who each suggested different medical treatment methods:

Calmovil Natural Hemorrhoid Remedy

Heals painful, itchy hemorrhoids quickly and naturally.

Scientifically Formulated Based on Clinical Research to:

Promote better blood flow
Stop itching and bleeding
Shrink hemorrhoids
Help dissolve existing blood clots
Relieve pain and pressure
Strengthen weakened veins
Prevent infections of hemorrhoids
Regulate digestive system

User Ratings 4.9 / 5

1. Rubber band ligation;

2. Milligan-Morgan technique;

3. Cryotherapy;

4. Stapler.

The patient specified that each specialist consulted only practices the technique that he personally deems most efficient. The problem raised, therefore, is that each specialist believes his technique (stapler, cryotherapy, ligation, etc.) to be the best, strongly advising against other techniques (without, however, clarifying the reasons for this). Purely based on acquaintances' experiences with the treatment, and the excellent results obtained, the patient would tend towards opting for cryotherapy (which would appear to be the least invasive, cheapest, and simplest technique, as it is generally carried out as an outpatient, with no particular preparation or hospital stay required).

Online Doctor Consultation - Medical Questions:

1) Will any of the techniques mentioned provide a definitive solution to the medical problem?

2) If so, which of the previously specified techniques can be considered best in terms of least sufferance during and post surgery? And which technique would allow the patient to return to normal activity (including non-competitive sports) the quickest?

The expert´s opinion

First of all I must emphasis that I have some doubt concerning the medical diagnosis and that some important details are missing. The medical report did not describe the physical rectal examination regarding the external anal component. This is important for choosing the best surgical technique and I will assume that there is no external component.

Options of treatment

Cryotherapy: (the option the patient mentioned he was leaning toward) this is a painful procedure, frequently associated with a profuse discharge and at least a week off work. Only about 50% of patients are well satisfied with the treatment. In terms of morbidity and time off work it is slightly better than hemorrhoidectomy, but the long term results are less predictable. It has more complications than does rubber-band ligation. Most proctologists have abandoned this technique.

60-Day Risk FREE Trial

People Said About Calmovil Hemorrhoid Remedy

"a week ago i was in agonizing pain. i was exausted and desparate for help. i though i would need a surgery, but i just couldn't imagine any sharp object anywhere near my butt. so i got calmovil. after 4 days my hemorrhoid got smaller and THE PAIN WAS GONE!" Jessica, Denver, CO

Rubber-band ligation: complications are infrequent with rubber-band ligation. Pain is usually mild and can be managed with analgesics. Return to work can be immediately or the day after treatment. The results of rubber-band ligation have been excellent with patient satisfaction of 80 to 91%. It must be emphasized that optimal treatment consist of 2-4 sessions with at least two weeks interval and depends on the number of hemorrhoids to be treated.

Milligan-Morgan operation: This is one of the most frequent techniques practiced. The operation is usually performed under general anesthesia, but spinal anesthesia can be used. The long term results are over 90% patient satisfaction. Pain is considered to be the main reason that patients resist the operation. It is evident that pain experienced after the operation is patient dependent. Hospital stay is about 1-2 days, but return to work is not for at least two weeks.

Stapled hemorrhoidectomy: This is relatively a new technique and is in practice for ten years. In all aspects it is an operation and must take place in the hospital. Patients report on less post operative pain compared to Milligan-Morgan operation and hospital stay is usually 1 day. The success rate is about the same as the former but there is one exception: the stapler technique is not effective for treatment of Hemorrhoids with an external component.

Conclusion: according to the information provided by the patient the most suitable technique of treatment is stapled hemorrhoidectomy since it is most effective and less painful than Milligan-Morgan operation. Rubber-band ligation, though excellent, is not indicated in this case. The rectal polyp should be excised in any case.

Learn More about Hemorrhoid Treatments

Internal Hemorrhoids Symptoms, Cause and Treatment

Internal hemorrhoids are unusually large and swollen veins in rectum. Because their origin is above dentate line they are usually painless. The fact that with internal hemorrhoids pain is felt only in later stages of sickness makes them harder to spot and treat. Internal hemorrhoids basically consist of tissue called ''anal cushions'', excessive pressure causes this tissue to swell and...

Hemorrhoids and Enlarged Rectal Veins

Hemorrhoids, in the rectum, occur when the veins are not returning enough blood back to the heart. When this happens, the vein walls do not receive enough oxygen and release a substance into the blood that causes them swell and become inflamed. This swelling weakens them and their more likely to break when they are rubbed, like during a bowel movement. If your stools are hard, you have a...

Hemorrhoids Symptoms

Hemorrhoid symptoms in general can include one or more of the following: Pain around the anus when sitting, standing or walking. Pain at the anus on passing a motion. Intense pain can be caused by thrombosed hemorrhoids, for the most past such pain is unbearable and you'll most likely head to the hospital or doctor. Discomfort on passing a motion. Discomfort - feeling...

Learn What Causes Hemorrhoids and What you Can Do to Avoid Them

Hemorrhoids are actually a very common occurrence that affects over half of the population over the age of 50 in North America. Anybody can develop hemorrhoids but there are certain conditions that can cause a person to develop this embarrassing and sometimes dangerous problem. The purpose of this article is to educate you on certain behavioral traits that can cause hemorrhoids and some ideas...

Best Options In Home Cures For Hemorrhoids

Hemorrhoids are a common ailment that strikes nearly eight in every ten people at some time in life. They can also be an embarrassing problem that many do not like to talk about, even to their own doctors. The good news is that there are many options in home cures for hemorrhoids that you can try from the comfort and privacy of your own home. However, if you suspect that you have a...